One sibling inherits with the others a house with a veranda that was never regularised, or with an amnesty application filed years ago and never closed by the municipality. People think that, until the file is in order, nobody can divide anything. That is not exactly so, but neither can the unauthorised building be divided as if nothing were wrong.
In 30 seconds
- Dissolving an inheritance co-ownership is subject to the planning nullity of art. 40 of Law 47/1985 and art. 46 of Presidential Decree 380/2001: an unauthorised building cannot be divided without the details of the building permit.
- But each co-heir can ask the court to dissolve the co-ownership for all the other inherited assets, excluding unauthorised buildings, even without the others’ consent.
- Before moving, collect the building files and have the situation checked by a technician.
Updated on 20 October 2026 (translation of the Italian original).
What the United Sections decided
In judgment no. 25021, filed on 7 October 2019, the United Sections of the Italian Court of Cassation stated three things.
- Dissolution of co-ownership is subject to planning nullity. Acts dissolving co-ownership of buildings, or parts of them, are hit by the nullity provided for acts between living persons when the details of the building permit do not appear.
- Division of an inheritance is an act between living persons. According to the Court, the act dissolving inheritance co-ownership is an inter vivos transaction, like the dissolution of ordinary co-ownership. The same nullity therefore applies.
- Enforcement and insolvency proceedings are excluded. Compulsory division in the forced sale of undivided assets, or in bankruptcy and other insolvency proceedings, is not hit by the nullity.
The other assets can be divided
This is the most useful point in practice. When the inheritance includes unauthorised buildings, each co-heir has the right, under art. 713, first paragraph, of the Civil Code, to ask for and obtain a court-ordered dissolution of the inheritance co-ownership for all the other inherited assets, excluding only the unauthorised buildings, even if the other co-heirs do not agree.
In practice, the building with the violation does not block the division of accounts, securities and other properties in good order. The unauthorised building stays out of the division until the details of the building permit exist.
Do you have a similar situation? You can submit your documents to the firm for an assessment.
What the rules say
- Buildings erected after 17 March 1985. Art. 46 of Presidential Decree 380/2001 declares null acts between living persons, in public or private form, that transfer, create or dissolve co-ownership of rights in rem relating to buildings, if the details of the building permit or the retroactive permit do not appear.
- Earlier buildings. Art. 40 of Law 47/1985 provides the same nullity if the details of the licence or concession do not appear, or if the amnesty application is not attached with proof of payment of the first two instalments of the fee. For works begun before 1 September 1967 a sworn substitute declaration is enough.
- Confirmation. If the omission of the details is not due to the permit not existing, the act can be confirmed, even by one party only, by a later deed containing the omitted statement (art. 46, fourth paragraph).
Agreement or lawsuit: what changes
| Agreement between co-heirs | Division lawsuit | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The co-heirs, together. | The judge, on the application of even one of them. |
| Unauthorised building | The deed must contain the details of the building permit, otherwise it is null. | The judge cannot divide it without the details of the permit; the other assets, yes. |
| Costs and time | Generally lower, if there is cooperation. | Generally higher, with expert reports and more hearings. |
No duration or figure is given: they depend on the number of assets and on the documents.
What to do now
- Retrieve the building files: building permit, amnesty applications and payment slips.
- Have a technician you trust check whether the works match the permit and whether they can be regularised.
- With a lawyer, assess whether to divide the other assets now and leave the unauthorised building out, or to regularise the file first.
Useful documents for the first meeting
Bring or send online, if you have them:
- the succession return and, if there is one, the will;
- title deeds and cadastral searches of the properties;
- building permits, amnesty and retroactive-permit applications, with payment receipts;
- cadastral plans and, if available, a technical report.
If something is missing, the meeting goes ahead anyway: the firm tells you how to obtain it.
Frequently asked questions
Does an unauthorised building block the division of the whole inheritance?
No. Each co-heir can ask for court-ordered dissolution for all the other assets, excluding unauthorised buildings, even without the others’ consent.
Is the division of an inheritance subject to planning nullity?
Yes. The United Sections consider it an act between living persons, like the division of ordinary co-ownership.
Does the nullity also apply in enforcement proceedings?
No. Compulsory division in the forced sale of undivided assets and in insolvency proceedings is excluded from the nullity.
How Avv. Fiorentino can assist you
- Examines the estate and the building files of the properties.
- Tells you which assets can be divided at once and which stay out.
- Sets up the agreement between co-heirs or, if needed, the division lawsuit.
The firm also follows you remotely: consultation with documents sent online, written quote before any engagement, offices in Naples (Piazza Giovanni Bovio 22 and Via Monte di Dio 14), Rome (Viale Giorgio Ribotta 21) and Bari (Via Domenico Morea 38) by appointment. The first consultation is held by appointment; a written fee quotation is given to you before any engagement (Law 124/2017).
Sources: Normattiva (Italian official legal database), Italian Court of Cassation. Informational content updated on 20 October 2026; it is not legal advice. Author: Avv. Renato Giuseppe Fiorentino, Naples Bar. This text was prepared with the help of artificial intelligence tools and reviewed by the lawyer.
Read also
Inherited property in Italy: how to divide or sell it when the co-heirs disagree
Forced heirship in Italy: who is entitled to a reserved share
Main page on this subject: Lawyer for inheritance matters in Naples and Campania.
