Update · Banks and companies in Italy
Bank guarantees in Italy (fideiussione): what changes after the 2026 Supreme Court ruling
Avv. Renato Giuseppe Fiorentino · 31 October 2026 · 6 min read
In 30 seconds
If you signed a personal guarantee (fideiussione) for an Italian bank, judgment no. 24825 of 28 August 2026 of the Joint Chambers of the Italian Supreme Court concerns you. For specific guarantees and for those signed outside the period examined by the Bank of Italy in 2005, the standard ABI form alone no longer proves that the unfair clauses are void. And if your contract contains an «on first demand» clause, a letter from the bank within six months is enough to keep its claim against you. Your defences, however, are not over.
References
Cass., Joint Chambers, no. 24825/2026Cass., Joint Chambers, no. 41994/2021art. 1957 Italian Civil Codeart. 1956 Italian Civil Code
Where the problem comes from
In October 2002 the Italian Banking Association (ABI) prepared a standard form of all-debts guarantee (fideiussione omnibus), later used by many banks. In 2005 the Bank of Italy (measure no. 55) found that three of its clauses, applied uniformly, breached competition law: the revival clause, the survival clause and the waiver of the six-month term of art. 1957 of the Civil Code.
In 2021 the Joint Chambers (judgment no. 41994) held that those clauses are void, while the rest of the guarantee remains valid, unless the parties are shown to have intended otherwise.
For the guarantor the stakes are high. Without the waiver, the bank must act within six months of the due date of the main debt. Otherwise it loses the right to claim payment from the guarantor.
What the Joint Chambers decided in 2026
Judgment no. 24825 was filed on 28 August 2026, following a referral from the Court of Siracusa in a case on specific guarantees signed in 2015. The Court published two headnotes (our translation):
«In the case of a specific guarantee reproducing the revival, survival and art. 1957 waiver clauses, the trial court must ascertain whether the contractual model used corresponds to an agreement or concerted practice restricting competition.»
«Where a guarantee contains a clause for payment on first demand, the creditor avoids forfeiture by sending an out-of-court request to the guarantor within the terms of art. 1957 of the Civil Code.»
First change: the date and type of guarantee matter
| Your guarantee | What you need to claim the clauses are void |
|---|---|
| All-debts guarantee signed in the period examined by the Bank of Italy (2002-2005) | The 2005 measure is still privileged evidence. It must be filed in court with the ABI form and your contract. |
| All-debts guarantee signed before or after that period | The measure is only «evidence not sufficient on its own». You must prove the clauses still resulted from an agreement between banks, for example by asking the judge to order the production of documents. |
| Specific guarantee (for one loan or mortgage) | Not excluded from protection, but the same additional evidence is needed. |
The bank, for its part, may show that the clauses were actually and freely negotiated. The Court of Naples, business section, rejected the claim of guarantors who had not filed the Bank of Italy measure and the ABI form (judgment no. 12226 of 14 September 2026).
Second change: with «on first demand» a letter is enough
Many Italian bank guarantees contain a clause for payment «on first demand» (a prima richiesta). According to the Joint Chambers, with this clause the bank avoids forfeiture by sending you an out-of-court request, such as registered mail or certified e-mail (PEC), within six months. It does not need to sue. This applies even if the waiver of art. 1957 is void.
The date on which you received the bank’s letter can therefore be decisive. Keep the envelope, the return receipt and PEC messages.
What the guarantor still has
- Forfeiture, if the bank let six months pass without any request or cannot prove you received it.
- Unfair terms: if you signed as a consumer (for example a parent or spouse with no role in the company), the waiver of art. 1957 can be challenged without proving any agreement between banks. The bank must show it negotiated the clause with you (Cass., order no. 27558 of 28 September 2023; Court of Naples, business section, judgment no. 6591 of 30 June 2025).
- Release under art. 1956 of the Civil Code, if the bank, without your authorisation, gave new credit to the debtor knowing its finances had worsened.
- Challenges to usury, compound interest and the balance of the guaranteed account.
Forfeiture must be raised in time, as a rule in the first defence brief. The Supreme Court has held that the guarantor must raise the objection promptly (order no. 267 of 7 January 2025).
What to do now
- Find your guarantee and check its date and type (all-debts or specific), and whether it contains an «on first demand» clause.
- Ask the bank for documents: a copy of the guarantee, the main contract and the account statements (art. 119 of the Italian Banking Act).
- Rebuild the timeline: due date of the debt or withdrawal of the credit line, first letter received, any payment order (decreto ingiuntivo).
- If you received a payment order, you usually have 40 days from service to oppose it, and longer if you live abroad. The exact term is written in the order.
Every case must be assessed on its documents. No outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Is a guarantee on the ABI form automatically void?
No. The three censured clauses may be void, not the whole guarantee. For specific guarantees and those signed outside 2002-2005, further evidence of the agreement is needed.
What changes for a bank asking for payment?
With an «on first demand» clause, the bank avoids forfeiture by sending you an out-of-court request within the terms of art. 1957.
I live abroad: can an Italian lawyer handle the case remotely?
Yes. Documents can be sent online and a power of attorney can be signed abroad. You receive a written fee quote before any engagement.
Where can I read the decision?
On the website of the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di cassazione), in Italian. The link is in the official sources below.
Official sources
How Avv. Fiorentino can help you
Avv. Renato Giuseppe Fiorentino, an Italian lawyer admitted to the Naples Bar and to the Supreme Court, has handled banking disputes and guarantees for over 25 years. Appointments in Naples (Piazza Giovanni Bovio 22 and Via Monte di Dio 14), Rome (Viale Giorgio Ribotta 21) and Bari (Via Domenico Morea 38). You can send documents online and receive a written quote before any engagement.
Information updated on 31 October 2026. It is not legal advice.
Come può seguirti l’avv. Fiorentino
Lo studio assiste privati e imprese a Napoli, Roma e Bari, e a distanza in tutta Italia. Prima dell’incarico ricevi un preventivo scritto (art. 13 L. 247/2012).
Richiedi una consulenza online
WhatsApp 347 5264190 · Chiama 347 5264190 · Scrivi all’avvocato
Sedi su appuntamento: Napoli, P.zza Giovanni Bovio 22 · Napoli, Via Monte di Dio 14 · Roma, Viale Giorgio Ribotta 21 · Bari, Via Domenico Morea 38 · P.IVA 06116130722
