Challenging a will in Italy for lack of capacity, fraud or undue influence over an elderly person

31 October 2026
In 30 seconds

  • A will can be challenged if the testator, when making it, was unable to understand and want (art. 591 of the Italian Civil Code).
  • It can also be challenged if the testator’s will was vitiated by mistake, duress or fraud, including undue influence over a vulnerable person (art. 624 c.c.).
  • Evidence is built from medical records, witnesses and a forensic medical report.
  • The time limits are five years, with different starting points: they must be checked at once.

Updated October 2026.

Illnesses that impair the mind, such as Alzheimer’s or vascular dementia, make wills made by frail elderly people in favour of their carers fairly common. When relatives discover such a will, they wonder whether it can be contested.

The testator’s natural incapacity

Persons who, even if not interdicted, are proved to have been incapable of understanding and wanting for any reason, even a temporary one, when they made the will are unable to make a will (art. 591, second paragraph, no. 3, c.c.). It is not enough that the person was old or ill: what counts is the situation at the exact moment of signing.

In general, whoever challenges must prove the incapacity. If, however, the testator suffered from a condition that habitually excludes the ability to self-determine, the case can become simpler for the challenger: it is then for whoever defends the will to show that it was made in a lucid moment. The burden of proof changes case by case.

Fraud and undue influence

A testamentary provision can also be challenged when it is the result of mistake, duress or fraud (art. 624 c.c.). We speak of undue influence (captazione) when someone, by fraudulent means, has diverted the testator’s will: for example by isolating them from their children or inducing them to make a will through deception. The action expires five years from the day the defect was discovered or ceased to operate, depending on the case (art. 624 c.c.).

How to prove it

  • Medical records and diagnoses: hospital stays, neurological or geriatric visits, cognitive tests, drug therapies.
  • Reports and certificates: disability, attendance allowance, assessments by cognitive disorder centres.
  • Witnesses: neighbours, doctors, relatives and carers who saw the testator’s behaviour.
  • Forensic medical report: reconstructs the clinical picture even after death, from the documents.

What to do now

  1. Get a copy of the will and check the date, the form and the notary.
  2. Ask for the medical documents: you will need proof of being an heir and formal requests.
  3. List the witnesses and the circumstances that show the change in behaviour.
  4. Have the deadlines and the route assessed. No route guarantees a result.

The best solution for you

  • If there is a documented serious diagnosis: a challenge for incapacity is considered, with an expert report.
  • If health was good but there was isolation or pressure: undue influence is considered, which is harder to prove.
  • If you are an excluded forced heir: also consider the action for reduction, which follows different rules.

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough that my father had Alzheimer’s?

No: you must prove that at the time of the will he was unable to understand and want, or that the condition was such as to habitually exclude lucidity.

Can I challenge even if I received something under the will?

Yes, if you have an interest in having the will set aside. The route depends on your position.

Does the person who cared for the elderly person lose the inheritance?

Only if the will is annulled; providing care is not wrongdoing in itself.

How attorney Fiorentino can help

  • Assesses the will and the available evidence.
  • Requests the medical documents and coordinates the expert report.
  • Assists you in mediation and, if needed, in court.

Write to us on WhatsApp Email · +39 347 5264190

The firm receives clients by appointment in Naples (Piazza Giovanni Bovio 22 and Via Monte di Dio 14), in Rome (Viale Giorgio Ribotta 21) and in Bari (Via Domenico Morea 38), and also remotely.

Sources: Italian Civil Code, arts. 591, 624; Normattiva. Author: attorney Renato Giuseppe Fiorentino, Naples Bar. General information: it does not replace advice on your case. Text written with the support of artificial intelligence tools and reviewed by the attorney.