How to contest a will in Italy: forced heirs’ share, incapacity, deadlines and calculation of the shares

31 October 2026
In 30 seconds

  • A will can be contested in two different ways: by an action for reduction, if it harms the share reserved to forced heirs, or by a challenge, if it is invalid (for example because the testator lacked capacity).
  • To know whether the share is harmed, the estate is notionally reunited: assets left minus debts, plus gifts made during life (art. 556 of the Italian Civil Code).
  • A challenge for incapacity must be brought within five years from the execution of the will (art. 591 c.c.). The action for reduction has its own time limits and should be assessed early.
  • Evidence matters: medical records, witnesses, comparison with the other provisions.

Updated October 2026.

When a will is opened, a child or the spouse may find they have been excluded or have received less than the law reserves to them. Before acting, you need to understand which route is the right one, because the two actions have different requirements and time limits.

Harm to the reserved share: the action for reduction

The law reserves a share of the estate to forced heirs: the spouse, the children and, if there are no children, the ascendants (art. 536 c.c.). If the will or gifts made during life reduce it, the forced heir may ask for the reduction of the provisions that exceed the disposable share (art. 554 c.c.). The will stays valid: it is reduced to the extent necessary.

How the share is calculated: the notional reunion

You calculate the value of the assets the deceased left at death, deduct the debts and add the value of direct and indirect gifts made during life (art. 556 c.c.). On the resulting mass you calculate the reserved share and the disposable share; then you check whether the deceased’s provisions exceed the disposable share. The calculation is technical and depends on the valuation of the assets: it is best done with a professional.

The testator’s incapacity and other defects

A will can be challenged if, when it was made, the testator was unable to understand and want, or for other defects of form and will (art. 591 ff. c.c.). For incapacity, the action expires five years from the day on which the provisions of the will were carried out (art. 591 c.c.). Whoever sues must prove the incapacity: medical records, neurological or geriatric certificates, witnesses and a technical expert report are used.

Deadlines: do not wait

  • Incapacity: five years from the execution of the will (art. 591 c.c.).
  • Reduction: the ordinary limitation period is ten years; the starting point and the exceptions, including towards third parties who bought the assets, must be checked on the specific case.
  • Acceptance of the inheritance: whoever brings an action for reduction must, as a rule, accept the inheritance with the benefit of inventory (art. 564 c.c.).

What to do now

  1. Get a copy of the will and check the date of publication.
  2. List the assets left, the debts and the gifts made during life.
  3. Collect medical documents and the names of possible witnesses.
  4. Have the route and the deadlines assessed right away: no route guarantees a result.

The best solution for you

  • If you were excluded but the testator was lucid: the usual choice is reduction, to recover the reserved share.
  • If there are signs of dementia or deception: a challenge to the will is considered, with expert reports.
  • If family relations allow it: negotiation through mediation can be faster.

Frequently asked questions

I was excluded from the will: am I entitled to anything?

If you are a child or the spouse, yes: the law reserves a share to you. To obtain it you must bring an action for reduction.

Does the will become void if it harms the reserved share?

No. It stays valid, but it can be reduced at the request of the forced heir.

Can I also act against gifts made during life?

Yes, within the limits set by law, after the estate assets have been exhausted.

How attorney Fiorentino can help

  • Assesses the will and chooses between reduction and challenge.
  • Prepares the calculation of the shares and the request for documents.
  • Assists you in mediation and, if needed, in court.

Write to us on WhatsApp Email · +39 347 5264190

The firm receives clients by appointment in Naples (Piazza Giovanni Bovio 22 and Via Monte di Dio 14), in Rome (Viale Giorgio Ribotta 21) and in Bari (Via Domenico Morea 38), and also remotely.

Sources: Italian Civil Code, arts. 536, 554, 556, 564, 591; Normattiva. Author: attorney Renato Giuseppe Fiorentino, Naples Bar. General information: it does not replace advice on your case. Text written with the support of artificial intelligence tools and reviewed by the attorney.